Originally published on 27 Feb 2017 10:13 PM
I am an Indonesian that went to Singapore university for 3 years and worked there for about 1 year. Even though Indonesia is one of Singapore’s closest neighbor, the difference between the two countries is staggering. As I live in the Jakarta (capital city), the comparison would be based between mostly Jakarta and Singapore. I’ll list down three major ones from my personal view.
A) Acceptance of Diversity
As one of the most diverse population, being in Southeast Asia, I’d say no country around here does diversity and multiculturalism better than Singapore. Southeast Asian population, in general, is very diverse, especially in terms of belief systems and cultural traditions. In Indonesia, we are as diverse as we can be as a country with thousands of islands, and that helps a lot on creating a space for tolerance in so many levels. But the greatest thing about being in Singapore, compared to Jakarta, is that there are always many different rooms for people to achieve something. People with particular skin colors are still somewhat stereotyped, both negatively and positively, but these are very trivial stuff that people talk about casually, not exactly something that might get you in major disadvantage in life. I’ll explain what I meant.
Indonesia might be very diverse in culture, but the fact remains we are not a country of diverse race. This, at times, could create a tension between some of the races here, namely between the Chinese descendants living in Indonesia with what some people called “indigenous people of Indonesia”. In the capital city Jakarta alone, you could be having a tough time entering few notable universities because of your skin color, or not getting the job you want on certain companies for the same reason. This might not be so obvious if you have western-look, or even, Japanese or Korean (surprisingly enough) as I’ve noticed this only happens mostly with the Chinese for reason I’ll leave you to find out yourselves.
B) Safety
As mentioned by other readers, public safety in Singapore is mind-bending. Even in the red-district of Singapore, and during its “peak hours”, I could walk around freely without feeling that I’m putting myself at great personal risk in any way imaginable. This is very useful, as the surrounding area of the city’s red district is one of many great place to try famous dishes unique to Singapore. Even when you are a woman, I don’t think you’ll get much worse than stares if you walk around at night around such places. Of course, this is not to say you should go out of your way to test the city’s safety, as major crimes do still exist in Singapore.
Don’t expect to feel so at ease going around places in Indonesia. From the general well-being safety to scammers, Indonesia is not a country you should be so lenient getting into. Even in Bali, one of the better island here for tourists and locals alike where it is generally so much safer for people to walk around late at night, you’d never run out of things to watch out for. Don’t get me to talk about Jakarta; if you don’t drive private vehicles here, going out alone at night, especially if you are a woman, would put you in unnecessary risks I’d tell people not to take.
C) Ease of Access
Despite the fact that living in Singapore is very expensive, it is one of the most livable city no matter where you came from. Adapting to life in other Southeast Asian countries could be a significant challenge. I’ve been on holiday to Kuala Lumpur, Bangkok, Ho Chi Minh to name a few, and even in such a short period of time I could already tell that life would be so much more difficult if I want to live there, compared to my stay in Singapore. It is indeed a very well-organized city with everything kept clean and available. Streets are well constructed and areas of the city very well-lit at night (even after midnight).
You can’t sleep at night? Just go downstairs to nearest 7-Eleven and have a snack with cup of coffee or whatever it is you like, sitting on the sidewalk enjoying the silence. If you are party-lover, take a taxi to the nearest late-night entertainment center on weekends; plenty of people would keep you entertained. You want to study or simply an avid reader? National Library is sitting there during open hours for you to explore the world through lines of texts. Cuisines from different countries of different tastes are for you to enjoy on just walking distance in between each every one of them. Can’t speak any Asian languages? Everything has English on it. The list goes on; none of the benefits I mentioned could be so readily available anywhere in Indonesia. Going out at night is a hassle, we don’t have decent public library (if there is any)*, and some of the more “exotic” cuisines usually are in niche restaurant category.
The city is of course far from perfect, but it is so very livable and accessible for everyone. As someone coming from a neighboring country, I find the disparity of my country and Singapore is exasperating.
[*] Update 24 March 2018: The National Library of Indonesia was officially opened on 14 September 2017, which set a milestone for Indonesia having the first mega-structured library with height of 126.3 meters tall and 24 stories, making it the tallest library in the world as per time of writing.
Footnotes